• Cheater’s Guide to Baseball

    I can't help but recommend this book to anyone and everyone who likes baseball... and even those who really don't. A funny book about all the cheaters in baseball? What can be better than that during the steroid era?

    Pre-order your copy of Cheater's Guide to Baseball by Derek Zumsteg of USSMariner.

  • Advertisements

What’s Wrong With Ichiro?

Posted by Jason A. Churchill on May 7, 2006

The M's right fielder and leadoff hitter entered the 2006 season with a career .331 average, a .378 on-base percentage and a .438 slugging percentage.

Through the first 32 games, Ichiro is sitting at .263/.329/.346 and appears to be a different hitter than he was prior to the 2005 season.

Since he broke George Sisler's single-season hits record in 2004, Ichiro has hit just .293, which for 95 percent of the players in baseball would be a great mark.

But it's nearly 40 points lower than Ichiro's career average.

So what's wrong with the M's offensive catalyst?

There are a lot of statistical areas in which Ichiro has been vastly different since 2004, starting with the number of times that he's hitting the ball in the air.

Through his first three seasons, Ichiro hit about 2.5 ground balls for every fly ball. In 2004, he peaked at 3.29.

Last season, he dipped to just 2.06 and thus far in 2006, Ichiro is hitting 1.93 ground balls to every one fly ball.

It's no wonder why he's not hitting for a high average.

You often hear myself and many others talk about G/F ratio for pitchers and how it's an advantage for pitchers to post high rates in that area, especially for the M's since they have plus defenders at three key defensive positions.

But it's also an important statistic for hitters like Ichiro. Even though pitchers with terrible G/F ratios have a better chance to blow up because fly balls produce more damage, fly balls are also more likely to result in outs than are ground balls, which would explain why Jarrod Washburn is a successful pitcher.

But Ichiro's skills are centered around his speed, bat control and ability to spray the ball around the diamond.

Hitting more fly balls is highly detrimental to his overall offensive approach.

From Jayson Stark's latest piece at ESPN.com:

"I'd like to see his ground-ball/fly-ball ratio," said one scout. "It seems like he's hit a lot more balls in the air than he used to." Bingo. Once, this guy was Edgerrin James. Now he's Marvin Harrison. Two years ago, Ichiro hit 3.29 ground balls for every fly ball. Last year, he was down to 2.06. This year, he's at 1.68 — or roughly half of where he was as recently as 2004.

"In the past, he wanted to be an on-base machine," the scout said. "Now it's almost like he's decided to try to hit some balls out of the park, and he's pulling the ball more. I feel like he can do anything he wants. He could hit 25 homers. He could hit .350. Whatever he feels like doing, he can do."

Well, he must feel like hitting well under .300 and hurting his team's chances to score enough runs to win, because that's what he's doing.

The difference between a 2.5 G/F rate and one around two even may seem somewhat insignificant, but it's approximately 35 ground balls per season for Ichiro.

In Ichiro's career, 40.2% of his ground balls have gone for hits. At that rate, those 35 extra ground balls would turn into about 15 hits, or 20 percentage points on Ichiro's batting average.

This would explain quite a bit.

Ichiro's line drive percentage is also down, about three percent. He's currently hitting line drives at an 18% clip, down from his career mark of 21.9.

A near 4% differential. Clearly, hitting line drives results in hits more often than any other type of hit. Four percent is equal to 28 at-bats for Ichiro in a typical season.

Combining those 28 fewer at-bats with the 35 fewer ground balls per season, Ichiro is giving away far too many at-bats in which he's hitting a pop-up or fly ball. He really isn't striking out at a higher rate, so fly balls are the result in question.

Some have pondered, 'is Ichiro swinging too early in the count?' He's really not, but maybe he should. His career average is .393 when swinging at the first pitch and it's currently .357 in the same situation this season.

He's seeing 3.9 pitches per plate appearance, which is up from about 3.5 for Ichiro's career. Ichiro has never posted a mark above the 3.58 he put up a year ago.

So maybe, on top of hitting too many fly balls and too few ground balls and line drives, Ichiro is being a tad too patient and is having to swing too often at the pitcher's pitch.

I don't think there is any maybe about it.

Ichiro has lost a step. He's not quite as fast as he was in years past, but the difference is negligible. Ichiro is not, however, using his speed like he once did.

One AL front-office man says: "I don't think necessarily that teams have adjusted to him. He's just changed a little bit, and I don't know what it is. The one thing I do see is, he doesn't bunt at all anymore."

He's attempted three bunts this season. He has just seven infield hits. 'Nuff said.

He's also pulling the ball a lot more often than in the past. Of his 272 hits in 2004, 66% went to left or center field and 67% of his non fly-ball outs went to left or center field. 81% of his fly ball outs went to left or center field.

In 2005, only 54% of his hits went to left or center, and 59% of his total outs went to those areas, not including fly ball outs which tend to be an overwhelming number hit to the opposite field for most hitters.

This season, just 51% of his hits have gone to left or center field. This is a trend Ichiro probably needs to turn around.

Blaming Ichiro entirely for his so-called slump isn't wise. The club did ask him to take more pitches last year and Hargrove is a big proponent of working the count, which Ichiro is doing. He's walked 10 times in 32 games, which paces him for 50 walks, which he's topped just once in his career.

But the key stat there is that only three of his bases on balls are intentional, a pace for 15, down from 23 a year ago and 19 in 2004.

What have we learned from all of this mumbo-jumbo data?

1. Ichiro is hitting the ball in the air too often

2. He's not bunting

3. He's pulling the ball too much

4. He's going deeper into counts than before

Maybe the solutions are;

1. Hargrove should call for him to bunt more, or just suggest it to him. It's a weapon that was overused in the past, but it can't be ignored. He must use his best attribute, his speed, to the fullest.
2. Let him swing at the first pitch if he wants to; .393 average is a good reason why. He's hitting just .239 this season when he doesn't swing at the first offering. If it's a pitch he likes, he should be swinging.

3. As far as his fly ball issues and his lack of spraying the ball to all fields like he used to? Maybe that's a result of Ichiro trying to win games for the M's by doing things that the rest of the lineup as a whole is not doing.

Can you blame him for trying?

Ichiro is still the best defensive right fielder in the last 30 years and is 9-for-12 in stolen base attempts, so his results at the plate are the only concerns.

Sounds like the mantra for the entire ball club right now, doesn't it?

Getting Ichiro back on the right track would be the best start to turning around the 2006 Seattle Mariners.

Photo Credits –

Ichiro: Associated Press


21 Responses to “What’s Wrong With Ichiro?”

  1. 2quarters said

    I’m hoping he’s not done…

  2. slim said

    I wonder if the trends in his G/F ratio are due to him feeling like he’s lost a step. If he believes he doesn’t have the speed to get on base like he used to, it may lead him to adjust his approach.

  3. Willmore said

    As long as we are on the “What’s wrong with …” topic, what’s wrong with Julio Santiago ? He left after facing just three batters tonight.

  4. slim, his GB/FB ratio changed after he set the record for hits in a season. If there was ever a time to not think he lost a step it was then.

  5. taro said

    Good post. He’s been experimenting with a power swing the last two years. Hargrove has also insisted on Ichiro being more patient.

    Ichiro is most effective when hes aggresively swinging for singles to the opposite field.

    Tell Ichiro to knock off the experiment and fire Hargrove, then you have 2004 Ichiro back.

  6. taro said

    His stance has changed as well – it looks similar to the leg kick he used in Japan when he’d swing for an extra-base hit. His most effective stance was the one he came up with in July of 2004. It cut down on his power but increased his reaction time, which is part of the reason he went on such a tear in the 2nd half.

    More importantly though, his approach is different. You can see it during his ABs. Early in the AB he is looking to lift the ball for power to all fields which cuts down on his ability to adjust to the pitch mid flight (since he has to commit to the pitch early) and also takes away his speed advantage (infield hits). When he gets to two strikes it seems he goes back to the old Ichiro.

    The key for Ichiro’s success is to swing for singles to the opposite field. He has a much better chance of hitting a line drive since he has that extra split second to react to the pitch, and even if he doesn’t he has a good chance of beating the ball out or finding a hole. Its the high percentage aproach with Ichiro.

    We shouldn’t be asking Ichiro to hit for power or take the first pitch. Hes a .380 slap hitter to the extreme.

  7. dnc said

    Off topic, but as you never give us a chance to comment on the sidebars, I’ll again comment in a nearby thread…

    “Stick to Pac-10 hoops, Steve”

    What?! For the love of all that is basketball, NOOOO! Physioc shouldn’t be allowed near a microphone period. The guy’s HORRIBLE at hoops. Sure that’s par for the course on Fox, but Physioc’s probably my least favorite of all the douchebags they employ.

  8. LOL, dawg. True!

  9. I never give you a chance? I can’t add a comments option to the right and lefthand notes area.

    I did, however, create a chat room and will add the link to the end of those from now on.

    The chat room is currently linked under the “linkage” category on the right side as “PI CHAT”.

  10. johnb said

    The new site seems to be working out pretty well. Why the exodus from ITP? Just for the record I prefer this as a forum.

  11. Joe and I just didn’t see eye to eye on what the new ITP was going to be like.

    I, too, much prefer this style.

    As soon as I find someone to help me design a site, I’ll go to the full dot com style, but with the same comments idea.

  12. cujo said

    Maybe he is sick of losing and tired of his lazy managers ways?

  13. slim said

    The other factor in Ichiro’s slump is the the M’s aren’t eliminated from the playoffs yet. The team has to be at least 10 games out of first place before Ichiro can start hitting.

  14. Synical Slim, synical.

    True, 100%, but synical.


  15. taro said

    Ironic that when Ichiro tries to help the team (and attempts to hit for power) he is ineffective, and when Ichiro plays selfishly he is a lethal leadoff man.

  16. Dave Cairns said

    Hi Jason

    I like the chat room, I had not noticed the link. My only problem is the time of day people are in the chat room !! A hassle about being on the other side of the world.

    I agree with Johnb the information and opinion is more informed here than itp and it is up to date.

    Thanks for keeping us informed on the m’s.

  17. I do what I can Dave.

    ITP, the web site portion was just too difficult to update daily, or several times a day.

    Otherwise, it woulda been easy to do then, too.

    I like it here. I just need a web designer!

  18. 1996Coug said

    My new favorite site. Kudos!

  19. J2D2 said

    You need a web designer? Let me know if I can help. (Your site is nice n’ tidy though; good job).

  20. Wow, thanks guys. I try.

    And yeah, J2D2, i’d like to spin this wordpress off on my own host, so i need someone who know how to do that, and a few other minor things in that manner. I don’t have the first clue.

  21. dnc said

    “I don’t have the first clue.”

    Pretty much sums it all up…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: